12

The close reason is very specifically: Technical Support of Modded Minecraft. Here's the definition from the Help Center: Troubleshooting and diagnosis of modded Minecraft, including crashes, startup errors or other abnormal behaviour caused by modding It might seem pedantic to point this out, but it leads in to my later point - this is a specific rule ...


3

I think it is a good fit for the minecraft-mods tag. The Minecraft questions on SO are more or less related to "real" Minecraft or plugin development (mostly Java) We already allow basic programming within the game's scope, such as command block chains and function files Carpet is a Minecraft mod, so the tag should be chosen accordingly As you already ...


3

The best I can say is try. Hopefully there is an answer, but if the thing itself is not finished, you run the risk of there not being a clear answer, or it being something only the developers can answer, which means it is something we won't be able to help with. As always, the more detail and clarity there is in your question, the better chance you have of ...


3

Questions about game design or development, including mods, have historically been considered off topic. They are, in general, welcome on GameDev.SE, so I'd encourage you to ask them there.


1

Behaviour Packs are not part of the base game. I think that logically excludes them. That functions are considered on-topic might have to do with their likeness - correct me if I'm wrong - to batch files and shortcut parameters, which are not that different from using in-game console commands and don't require any third-party software. But! this is also ...


1

I don't really see a problem here. As guidelines, those close reasons demarcate the limits of what this community can be asked about. Those guidelines shift and evolve, along with this community's territory. If a certain problematic situation, which is exceptionally hard to solve, is found to generally be tied to a specific game (or console, or genre, for ...


Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible