Last week (reopen, I think), I came across this question, I think in the review queue, not sure. Either way, I didn't act on it, since I'm not really a Dota 2 person, and that Skip button is always a correct option. But one of the comments caught my attention.

What I found interesting - 4 of 5 users who voted for this dota-2 question as for opinion-based have no dota tags at all :)

From my reading of it, I thought it a bit rude. The commenter (also OP) sounds to me like they're saying that 80% of the people closing the question should butt out of tags they don't understand; they're chastising the people who closed it, basically. So, I flagged it as 'rude or offensive', because, well, it's rude. The flag was declined.

I'm okay with that; it's not really directly rude, mostly just passively so, if you read into it a certain way. And offensive flags do usually tend to be reserved for more severe stuff, since offensive flags on posts have some pretty sharp teeth. Fair enough.

But there's no way I can possibly read it as constructive. It doesn't add information to the post. It neither provides nor asks for clarification. It doesn't add anything useful at all. All it does is sit there, chastising four people for closing a question. It's a wart on the question, so I re-flagged as Not Constructive. That got declined, too.

I kinda want to flag it again (and both the other comments about the closure, too) as being 'obsolete', since that applies too; the question was re-opened successfully several hours after they were all posted. But, having some common sense (On a good day. I swear. No, really.), I instead figured I'd pop here on Meta and ask: what's so constructive about this comment that it was judged worth keeping?

  • 1
    Comment flags tend to be handled differently based on who's looking at them. For instance, there was another comment after those that was even worse than that one. Flagging it as non-constructive didn't help that one, either. – Frank Jun 12 '14 at 3:38
  • 5
    Rude is not the same as not constructive – badp Jun 12 '14 at 7:26
  • 2
    @badp Don't see anywhere I suggested they were. This comment just happened to be both. And also obsolete. – Billy Mailman Jun 12 '14 at 10:41
  • thinking that only experts at something can notice that you're asking for personal opinions about it is telling... – jwenting Jun 17 '14 at 6:49

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .