Take this question for example, which has been closed: Suggest a (steampunk) deepsea game.
The OP is asking for a game suggestion, of a very specific kind. And it has been closed as "too localized", and commented as "too limited in scope, there can't be an answer".
"Too localized" applies to questions which are too narrow in time, or in geographical situation. We don't want to have questions linked to only one country/region, or linked to a particular date, this is why such close reason exists. This is not such a situation.
There is no good reason to close this question. If it's too specific and there is really no answer... Then it will be forgotten the next day, no harm. If there is an answer, now or later, it will be given, and that's good. Nobody can claim to know any possible game.
We are complaining that people ask too wide "game rec" questions, and closing them. And when someone comes and ask a very specific one... it gets closed again. Let's be lighter on this kind of moderation.