10

Seems someone changed the [game-recommendations] tag to [game-rec] tag retroactively - i.e. not by manually going over each question.

Why is that? I think [game-rec] is very bad, as it's not clear what "rec" is. Is it short for "recommendation"? For "recreational"? Maybe it's a gaming genre I'm just not familiar with, something like "running empty corridors"?

I thought we reached a conclusion that we should avoid short forms of tags, so I would like to understand what's the reason for shortening here. I'm not familiar with "rec" being a common English slang for "recommendation".

I propose that the tag be changed to [game-recommendation] (minus the final 's' in the previous version, though, that was odd).

  • 1
    Especially given that tags are auto-completed, what's the problem with extending rec to recommendation? – Ivo Flipse Jul 16 '10 at 7:29
  • It is also similar to policy of other SE sites, like webapp-rec for example. – user59 Jul 16 '10 at 7:46
  • It stands for game records... ... ... – BlaXpirit Oct 8 '10 at 21:03
6

I suggest changing game-rec to recommendation for the time being.

Rationale:

  • I don't see why any tag here should ever have game in it. It's a given it's going to be about games!
  • rec as a prefix could be recommend but also recognise, which makes it confusing (I was about to ask why do we have identify-this-game if we have game-reccomendation... oh wait).
  • For why we picked [game-recommendations] instead of [recommendation] before, see the comment exchange between myself and Noctrine at meta.gaming.stackexchange.com/questions/217/…. – Grace Note Jul 29 '10 at 18:27
  • Meh, @grace, peripheral recommendations are either still recommendation (but with the joystick/etc. tag) or another tag. – badp Jul 29 '10 at 19:28
4

From chat:

Ivo Flipse: @Jeff did you change the games-recommendation to games-rec?

Jeff Atwood: yeah I hate "recommendation" as a tag..

4

Two things

  1. Recommendation is a poor concept on our sites. "Recommend me a computer to buy! Recommend me a game to play on my VIC-20!" So the presence of this tag is like a big "this question is very likely to suck" sticker slapped on it.

  2. Recommendation is far, far too long as a tag. Recommendation is both "long and wide" -- it is a long word for # of letters and because the individual letters it contains in a proportional font are also wide.

    compare:

    IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
    MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM

    same # of letters.

  • 7
    Regarding (1) - that's a topic for a different question. Regarding (2) - I understand where you're coming from, but if I was a new user I'd hesitate before picking game-rec as a tag, simply because I would not understand what it means. And I think this situation is far worse than having a slightly long tag, especially compared with other tags here in gaming, many of which are game names which are anyway long. Maybe we should just go with [recommendation], without the "game-" part. It's shorter and still obvious. – Oak Jul 16 '10 at 8:59
  • @oak "I'd hesitate.." good, that is completely intentional, because we don't want these kinds of questions anyway. also note that we already have -rec tags on SU. So you're bucking convention here, and I'm very likely to overrule you: superuser.com/tags – Jeff Atwood Jul 16 '10 at 9:36
  • 1. See, that's one of the cases where a fourth place would come in handy... – Zommuter Jul 16 '10 at 10:17
  • Well, all my arguments got shot down once you pointed out that SU uses the -rec tags. Well, if this helps reduce the number of recommendation questions, I see it as an overall benefit. – Grace Note Jul 16 '10 at 11:56
  • Also, as proven in the title, "recommendation" is not easy to type right every time. – Gnoupi Jul 16 '10 at 13:18
  • If you're looking for something not as wide, why not game-suggestion? – Corey Jul 18 '10 at 2:02
  • I'm not sure people hesitating to put any tag with the question is the right move. It seems to me that this will cause questions to simply come up mis-tagged, rather than not asked at all. "rec" is just not a clear abbreviation at all. – Jeffrey Jul 29 '10 at 19:43
  • @Gnoupi, autocompletion ftw :) – badp Jul 30 '10 at 11:51
1

I know it seems almost asinine, but why not game-recs as a plural form?

  • The questions inherently afford the suggestion of multiple titles / games that someone would like to play.
  • It would reduce some (not all, though) of the ambiguity on what rec means. As Oak mentioned above, rec could be mistaken for recreational. This would deter that line of thought.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .