4

So I posted this answer where I suggest this cool Ibuki guide I read once. The OP tried to download it and it does not work anymore.

I do have the guide on my computer though and it is free.

What should I do?

Here are some things I have thought of:

  • Remove the reference entirely.
  • Leave the reference, as someone might want to ask the admin of the site (crosscounter) to fix this.
  • Add the file to some hosting site like uploaded.to and link this URL instead. I am not sure about the copyrights though.

Obviously I cannot summarize the content as it includes specific combos and strategies on over 40 pages.

| |
  • Something you can always do is take the original work and rewrite it with your own words. Copyright does not protect the facts and idea behind a writing, only the writing itself. – badp Jul 12 '12 at 9:29
11

Never wholesale copy a copyrighted work without adhering to its license: if no license is supplied, all rights are reserved and only fair use/dealing applies, meaning you can't re-host the work elsewhere without express permission of the copyright holder.

Ideally, as an exercise in fair use, you should always excerpt1 the relevant part of the guide when writing your answer in addition to linking to the full guide. This way if link rot occurs, the information is still available within the context of the larger answer.

But since that didn't happen and the guide is no longer available, the reference to the guide should be removed. It doesn't look like your answer significantly changes if you remove the following line:

Crosscounter created a quite good free guide that explains everything.

Of course, if someone wants to ask the admin of the site to re-host the guide or make it available under terms that let you re-host it elsewhere, awesome: add back the reference when it becomes available again. An alternative would be to find another guide that contains a similar explanation to what you wanted to reference. Just remember to include an excerpt if either happen.

Note 1: there is no standard or accepted amount for what constitutes fair use and what amounts to wholesale copying, but a rule of thumb I use is that a) the excerpt should not be the main thrust of the larger work (your answer), and b) the excerpt should not completely obviate the value of the guide.

| |
  • I have contacted the site owners and if they do not answer of fix the issue within 2 days I will remove the link as suggested. – ayckoster Jul 12 '12 at 0:51

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .