As established in Pokemon tag problems (Gotta Tag 'Em All), we handle Pokémon main series game tags in the following manner:
- Generation Tag: pokemon-xxxxxth-generation - for questions about the Xth generation of games, that aren't specific about any individual game.
- Game Tags
This is generally great and works well for our format, we haven't had any major issues with this (barring one tag length issue).
However something about this has irked me for years - the first two generations of Pokémon games do not have a secondary set of games, or a 'different story' split to necessitate a "generation vs game name" tag split. Thus, for these cases, the generation tag is the only tag for these games. i.e.
I personally think this makes these tags harder to use. For every other game on the site, including later Pokémon generation games, the game names still exist as a full tag, and thus I think it would be better we used pokemon-red-blue-yellow-green and pokemon-gold-silver-crystal as the main tags (leaving all the same synonyms in place). In other words:
What do you think? Does this make sense?