How did I review stuff incorrectly?

Question

I am suspended from reviewing because I reviewed stuff incorrectly. All the stuff I reviewed ended up getting deleted by a moderator and on all of them I had:

• Upvoted a comment saying that’s not how things are said
• Left a comment asking for better

Here are the links for the questions I reviewed wrongly:

• Answer to "Sharing game between devices?"
• Answer to "Blocks mysteriously disappearing in minecraft?"
• Answer to "How can I restart my game?"
• Answer to "When being a werewolf, is there a way I can heal my self?"
• Question: "How do you give a name, lore, and enchantments in Minecraft using a single Command Block? (Bedrock Edition 1.16)"

Can someone tell me what I did wrong? Is upvoting someone else’s comment saying the question was not asked correctly not enough?

Answer 1

In the First Posts and Late Answers review queues, only 1 "Reviewed" or "No Action Needed" review takes the item out of the queue. While comments stating that a post is not an answer are nice, all of these posts required further attention. In these cases, the correct action would have been to flag the post as Not An Answer, marking them for further review in the Low Quality Posts and moderator queues.

The last one is of course a question, which is slightly different but similar. In that case, rather than just posting a comment that their question has an answer in another place, the correct action would have been to flag the post as a Duplicate.

We understand that it can be frustrating to be locked out of the queues, but correct reviews are important for us to maintain quality on the site, and flags are essential to identifying low quality posts.